ISSUE №207 · POSITIONING | DEMAND GEN | SALES

SPONSORED

In 1971, a guy named Ray Tomlinson sent the 1st “modern” email (seriously - check it). Ever since then, email tools have been getting harder and harder to use because we are cramming more stuff that you don’t need into them. On top of that, email software pricing has gone through the roof. iContact thinks that email software ought to be easy to use, powerful & affordable.

So that’s exactly what they’ve done. Full featured email - campaigns, automations, integrations with major CRMs, funnel builders and bazillions more through Zapier - easy to use drag and drop interface…it’s just what you need in an email marketing suite. And they have an agency set up that allows you to manage clients through 1 log in. And get this - you get a 30 day free trial AND PLANS START AT JUST $9/MO. Go forth and email my friends, go forth with iContact.

PS: The folks at iContact didn't ask me to talk about this, but if you saw the news recently, the Harambe-themed email software company was just acquired by Bending Spoons. If recent patterns hold true, all of you folks who use the banana-loving email platform will be seeing a seriously ugly price increase sometime in the next few months. Get ahead of that and check out iContact ASAP.

We’ve Done A LOT Of Yapping Recently About Customer Fit - So Let’s Bring It All Together

There are a couple of themes that show up again and again and again here in the hallowed halls of Agency Inner Circle HQ:

  1. Return on Understanding: This is the yield that you get when you have a deep understanding of your clients' needs, their strategic goals, their marketplace, and perhaps more than anything, the mechanics of their business. From the 2025 Setup Marketing Relationship Survey, marketers gave these reasons for breaking up with their agencies - and if you understand your client and their business really well, these things just don't pop up:

    1. Agency did not understand our business (44%)

    2. Dissatisfaction with relationship (41%)

    3. Dissatisfaction with strategic approach (41%)

  2. Vibes, Vision & Value/s: Think of your vibes, vision, and values as the essential parts of your agency culture that clients might find attractive. I don't mean a cool working space or a nifty logo, but sharing your actual way of working, way of thinking, and the things that you know are important are going to attract some buyers more than others. For instance, anyone who works with me has to be comfortable with direct communication, occasional profanity, and regular jokes that amuse me. That’s my vibe. People who don't want that vibe and want something very procedural and structured aren't likely to really race towards me and get excited when we have a call and I drop three F-bombs, 2 Friends references (current favorites are Pivot! & Chandler’s Dad - FYI), and shit on the current presidential administration with abandon. My vibes scare away the folks I can’t help as well. Your VVV ought to grab hold of those that you connect with best - a shared VVV is amongst the best ways to generate the highest possible ROU (Return on Understanding)

  3. Build A Beacon: Once you’ve got your ROU and your VVV locked in. You've got to build a beacon to attract clients. You've got to create content. You've got to create agency assets. You've got to create a way for people to know that you exist and give them a reason to engage with you.

  4. Get Into The Consideration Set: All of these things are designed to help you get into the consideration set of your desired client targets. While that isn't the end game, but becoming part of your target market's consideration set is crucial to your survival, so you need to understand how businesses are choosing agencies these days. You need to really understand how your market sorts the possibilities of agency partners because there are a bazillion agencies all saying the same thing in the same way, and it becomes impossible for prospects to discern one agency from another if you haven't figured out your ROU, your VVV, and your Beacon.

  5. You Need To Discover The Real Goals: The the place where most agencies fall apart is in the discovery call, because they turn what is supposed to be an opportunity to increase their understanding of the prospect, their problems, and their opportunity. They start selling because they are so desperate to close a sale. This is a truly common error that eliminates trust, and moreover, it eliminates your ROU advantage. Read my discovery call playbook, or some discovery focused AIC issues, learn about the difference between a discovery call and a sales call or check out my free Discovery Lab call prep tool.

  6. Don’t Sell Like An Asshat - Use The WTF Sales Methodology: throughout this process, we have really focused on understanding and being transparent, and I want you to carry that all the way through the sales process. WTF Sales is really about trust. It isn't about home-run offers or forced commitments. It's really about mutual understanding and respect. (You might want to read my end to end agency sales playbook, too.)

This Is, Essentially, The Front End Throughline of How To Grow Your Agency

Of course, this is a quick snapshot of modern agency sales and marketing. And, of course, every agency faces different circumstances, but as we roll into the end of the year, I really want to start wrapping up all of the things that you want to be focused on for 2027. I know that this high-integrity, high-trust, high-understanding way of thinking probably feels so much harder than sending out 10,000 cold emails and doing a one-call close.

It isn't. It's actually way easier because you don't have to pretend to be a magician. You get the chance to investigate your client's needs and opportunities. You give yourself time to create a strategy that fits your client's particulars. You give your team enough context so they can hit the ground running without spending the first 60 days of an engagement uncovering the things that should have come up during the sales process.

Why Is This Important Right Now?

I've had so many conversations over the past few months with agencies that are struggling to articulate their value. Not their values as in deep customer relationships, treating your team well, and doing the right thing even when it's hard. Not those, but their actual financial economic impact.

We are in a dramatic cultural change where the information that agencies possess about how to execute marketing tactics is substantively less valuable than it was just 2 or 3 years ago. I used to say that any marketing tactic or advice you need is already on YouTube. Somebody has 100% already walked through the process that you need to execute in order to create results.

With the advent of AI, you don't even have to watch the videos anymore. You can give a set of circumstances to a well-informed, high-context agent, and they will come up with something that is passable. I won’t say that AI is taking our jobs because it's not. It is changing the way we show our value

We Are Moving To World Where Process Matters Less & Outcomes Matter More

In so many ways, your clients want to know the sausage is delicious. They don't give a shit about how you made it. But in order to create the outcomes that truly matter to your clients, you need to have a true and deep understanding of what's important to them. You need to understand their economics, their culture, their clients' culture, their market, their operations, and the only way to get all of that information is to be authentic and safe and kind with your insight.

Marketers who engages with agencies rarely listens to an idea or an approach that an agency has and says, "Oh hell, we can do that ourselves." You might see it a little bit more because AI makes things seem easier than they actually are, but the reason why marketers engage with agencies isn't for outsourced labor, and it's not for a set of deliverables. It is for the insight and decision-making that comes with breadth of experience.

AI hasn’t taken that away - in fact It has made it more important. AI is so terrific at giving an authoritative answer with mostly assumed, conflated context. If you've noticed when AI does marketing, it often confuses the context of the seller and the buyer, and what's inside information and what's outside information. That's why so much AI-written text in marketing makes you think, "What the fuck are they talking about?"

As an agency trying to make your way through this dramatic upheaval, I think the single most important thing that you can do today is to be able to understand the outcomes that will really matter to your clients and market. And no, for the love of gawd, outcomes are not return on ad spend or any other bullshit marketing metric. And rarely is it revenue… most marketers want revenue that has a particular flavor or shape. They want revenue from new clients, or in a particular product line, or from a particular set of companies in their target market.

When a prospect or client gives you a simple metric to hit, like return on ad spend, revenue, or conversion rate. they are actually telling you that they don't trust you enough to let you in to truly understand what their strategic needs are.

That’s why this authentic, high-context, high-information, deep-discovery, high-trust kind of sale is so crucial. There are many times when a marketer will hire an agency because they need something done, but they don't trust that agency enough to bring them close enough to show them what their business is hungry for. Those are the clients that pay late, aren’t kind to your team, elevate everything to your leadership team, and eventually churn.

Looking forward to getting you ready for 2027 - it’s gonna be nuts.

Quick Notes: